From his 2020 album, Quiet, Heavy Dreams, Zach Bryan’s “Birmingham” offers an experience like no other including murder, regret, and even levels of self discovery in one’s final moments. The song falls into it’s own sub-genre of music called murder ballads, a story of a murder and the events either before or after. Zach Brown’s is about a man who killed a man in self defense and is just looking for a way out. Stressed from his job, he goes on the run and ends up in a fight with the police in which he dies. He has worries and regrets because of how he was seen in he end, but ultimately just wants it all to be over with and move one.
The song’s opening line does a lot to set the scene and even give a motive. These lines tell us of his horrible conditions and how fed up he was. We also see some of his feeling for the first time, however they feel over shadowed by his want to leave everything.
Well, I killed a man in Birmingham
I hit him with a tire iron
He did not move, and I do not give a damn
I’ve been working here like a slavin’ mule
Sucking the earth of dry crude
Looking for a way out of it all
The line “working here like a slavin’ mule” stuck out to me first. Mules are an animal that are almost exclusively used for labor, and made to work a lot weather its carrying or pulling something. Also not only are his working conditions like that, but it says something to his job as a whole. Bosses treating they’re employees like livestock, making them work tirelessly with little to no break or pay presumably. Working in what we can assume to be an oil field, it is understandable that with the dehumanization he has endured, hes just looking for a way out.
So take me down to the river
My blood all on the floor
‘Cause I don’t know if I can carry this weight much longer anymore
Take me up the mountain
On a cloud bound for the sky
Don’t go prayin’ for me because tonight I’m prepared to die
In the chorus of the song we see a lot of acceptance of whats to come, as if whether he saw it coming or not, he ready and just wants it over with. We see a river used a lot in literature as a way of crossing and i feel like its the same here. It could be a literal river like hes fleeing, but I think more accurately its the river of life and he’s ready to cross over after his fight with the cops. Especially with his blood on the floor, as if laying in a pool of it, he knows the end is coming, and doesn’t want to endure the weight of a murder n his conscience anymore, so he just wants it to end. The cloud bound for the sky symbolizes afterlife but more specifically heaven, which shows that even after the murder, he believes himself to be a good person. He also says to not pray for him because he is prepared to die. Usually when you pray for somebody its for safety or good health, maybe even innocence, however he is aware he has none of these so he’s saying don’t bother, because hes expecting to die.
That night out there in Birmingham, that boy he tried to rob me
I did not want to, but I had to show that boy the real me
That night I often wonder what my tombstone would say
Would it mention any of my good or just evil in my days?
The dust has not settled, from the boys who busted in
I am not a bad man but there’s bullets in my skin
Here we see the first mention of a motive or the reason behind the murder. We can now assume it was in self defense that he killed the boy, however we also see how much he didn’t want to go through with it. Between the line of not wanting to show the real him and the many lines of regret following it we start to see his honest feelings of the event. In his last moments hes wondering what his tombstone will say, wondering if it will have some of his good or only his bad, implying he has a good amount of both. Along with the final line and his continued proclamation of not being a bad man, followed by his death. This whole song is a story of his death and many regrets however all with the same message. Acceptance of his death and knowing he deserves it for murder, he almost begging not to been seen as a bad man as if he expects that’s what coming. He believes hes going to heaven and has done a lot of good in his life but is worried none of that will be passed on and he will only be seen as evil for killing a boy.